选课中心
7099人选课
GMAT公开讲座
0元
GRE公开讲座
0元
一对一体验课
99元
GMAT模考网站
10000人
GRE模考网站
GMAT课程
GRE课程
托福辅导课程
【定制】1v1
私人订制
资料下载
考前冲刺
扫码添加助教
免费领取
备考资料大礼包
扫码关注公众号
本文来自GMAT阅读题库(点击查看更多),为考生提供GMAT阅读题目练习及答案解析,希望对大家GMAT备考有所帮助。点击下载更多GMAT备考必备资料。更多精彩尽请关注新东方在线GMAT频道!
GMAT阅读题目内容
In Winters v. United States (1908), the Supreme Court held that the right to use waters flowing through or adjacent to the Fort Belknap Indian Reservation was reserved to American Indians by the treaty establishing the reservation. Although this treaty did not mention water rights, the Court ruled that the federal government, when it created the reservation, intended to deal fairly with American Indians by reserving for them the waters without which their lands would have been useless. Later decisions, citing Winters, established that courts can find federal rights to reserve water for particular purposes if (1) the land in question lies within an enclave under exclusive federal jurisdiction, (2) the land has been formally withdrawn from federal public lands—i.e., withdrawn from the stock of federal lands available for private use under federal land use laws—and set aside or reserved, and (3) the circumstances reveal the government intended to reserve water as well as land when establishing the reservation.
Some American Indian tribes have also established water rights through the courts based on their traditional diversion and use of certain waters prior to the United States’ acquisition of sovereignty. For example, the Rio Grande pueblos already existed when the United States acquired sovereignty over New Mexico in 1848. Although they at that time became part of the United States, the pueblo lands never formally constituted a part of federal public lands; in any event, no treaty, statute, or executive order has ever designated or withdrawn the pueblos from public lands as American Indian reservations. This fact, however, has not barred application of the Winters doctrine. What constitutes an American Indian reservation is a question of practice, not of legal definition, and the pueblos have always been treated as reservations by the United States. This pragmatic approach is buttressed by Arizona v. California (1963), wherein the Supreme Court indicated that the manner in which any type of federal reservation is created does not affect the application to it of the Winters doctrine. Therefore, the reserved water rights of Pueblo Indians have priority over other citizens’ water rights as of 1848, the year in which pueblos must be considered to have become reservations.
3、Which of the following most accurately summarizes the relationship between Arizona v. California in highlight text, and the criteria citing the Winters doctrine in the last sentence of first paragraph?
A.Arizona v. California abolishes these criteria and establishes a competing set of criteria for applying the Winters doctrine.
B.Arizona v. California establishes that the Winters doctrine applies to a broader range of situations than those defined by these criteria.
C.Arizona v. California represents the sole example of an exception to the criteria as they were set forth in the Winters doctrine.
D.Arizona v. California does not refer to the Winters doctrine to justify water rights, whereas these criteria do rely on the Winters doctrine.
E.Arizona v. California applies the criteria derived from the Winters doctrine only to federal lands other than American Indian reservations.
GMAT直播VIP小班 | GMAT直播精讲班 | GMAT录播课 |
(VIP小班/全科班+1对1) | (全科精讲/单项备考) | (全科班/单项班) |
72.5课时 ¥18800 | 61课时 ¥7796 | 134课时 ¥14680 |
资料下载
新东方GMAT佛脚词汇1.0版本
发布时间:2023-06-30添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
新东方GMAT数学500题资料下载
发布时间:2023-05-26添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
新东方GMAT800题资料下载
发布时间:2022-05-21添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
1000句GMAT真实句子改错问题
发布时间:2022-04-17添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
2024杨鹏阅读难句(GMAT+GRE)教程
发布时间:2022-04-17添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
新东方GMAT数学500题(解析及答案)
发布时间:2019-11-27添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
新东方GMAT800题(逻辑+语法+阅读)
发布时间:2019-11-27添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
新东方GMAT佛脚词汇1.0版本
发布时间:2019-11-27添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
GMAT词汇/长难句/语法资料大全
发布时间:2019-11-27添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
GMAT语文考试圣经(Bible)电子版
发布时间:2019-11-27关注新东方在线美研订阅号
回复【GMAT】获取
GMAT推理圣经PDF电子版
发布时间:2019-11-27添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
GMAT考试OG五个版本题号对照表
发布时间:2019-11-27添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
GMAT Ultimate Grammar电子书籍PDF
发布时间:2019-11-27添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
添加美研助教号,
回复【GMAT】获取备考必看资料包
推荐阅读
更多>>新东方在线GMAT频道为大家带来GMAT阅读复习的五大步骤,希望对大家GMAT备考有所帮助。更多精彩尽请关注新东方在线GMAT频道! 1:原来
新东方在线GMAT频道为大家带来GMAT阅读背景的培养,希望对大家GMAT备考有所帮助。更多精彩尽请关注新东方在线GMAT频道! 一、经济学
新东方在线GMAT频道为大家带来GMAT阅读复习效率不高怎么办,希望对大家GMAT备考有所帮助。更多精彩尽请关注新东方在线GMAT频道! 建
新东方在线GMAT频道为大家带来GMAT阅读提高速度的根本方法,希望对大家GMAT备考有所帮助。更多精彩尽请关注新东方在线GMAT频道! 1
新东方在线GMAT频道为大家带来GMAT阅读如何避免错误,希望对大家GMAT备考有所帮助。更多精彩尽请关注新东方在线GMAT频道! 要避免GMA
新东方在线GMAT频道为大家带来GMAT阅读技巧的提升,希望对大家GMAT备考有所帮助。更多精彩尽请关注新东方在线GMAT频道! GMAT阅读推
新东方在线GMAT频道为大家带来GMAT阅读备考的注意事项,希望对大家GMAT备考有所帮助。更多精彩尽请关注新东方在线GMAT频道! GMAT阅
新东方在线GMAT频道为大家带来GMAT阅读怎么提高自己的能力,希望对大家GMAT备考有所帮助。更多精彩尽请关注新东方在线GMAT频道! 建
新东方在线GMAT频道为大家带来GMAT阅读长句子的备考,希望对大家GMAT备考有所帮助。更多精彩尽请关注新东方在线GMAT频道! 1 首先
新东方在线GMAT频道为大家带来GMAT阅读水平怎么提高,希望对大家GMAT备考有所帮助。更多精彩尽请关注新东方在线GMAT频道! 下面就来
资料下载
更多>>添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
关注新东方在线美研订阅号
回复【GMAT】获取
添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
添加新东方美研助教号
回复【资料】获取
阅读排行榜
相关内容